The case against case studies
In a terrific article which just came out in the February 4, 2008 edition of Business Week, author Geoff Gloeckler describes how Columbia Business School is getting away from conventional case studies, instead using ‘decision briefs’ that are more like the situations managers would face in real life than the detailed, deeply researched cases that often form the basis of a business school curriculum. The goal is to help MBA’s develop better skills at making sense of ambiguous information. You’ll find the complete article here.
The move away from cases in the MBA program actually mirrors what we’ve been doing in Executive Education programs for years. We find that executives have so much interesting and rich context that they bring into the classroom that cases aren’t that useful (besides who wants to wade through 30 or 40 pages of a lengthy case?). We tend to use a lot of short case-ettes, actual stories from the company, and even clips from newspapers and magazines to get the discussion started. Not only is it more interesting for the participants, it does force the frameworks and tools you use to be very real-world.
Among my favorite short cases are the “Spinbrush” story from Proctor and Gamble and a short case detailing the end of life of the Victor Talking Machine Company of Camden, New Jersey.
Share this article: 
- Posted: Monday, February 04, 2008
- Permalink
Next entry: Discovery Driven Planning: Different from conventional planning Previous entry: Business School Rankings: Hungry for Lists?
I’m glad to see Columbia challenging the use/overuse of traditional case studies. They can play a role, but simply relying on dusty old stories doesn’t challenge students enough. I, too, wrote about the Business Week article, from the perspective of the “worked examples” approach to teaching complex cognitive skills.
nice site
recent entries
- Will Facebook’s IPO re-ignite growth in Silicon Valley?
- Why just being young is not a reason to doubt Facebook
- Why advertisements need to get a whole lot better before they will support social media
- Bing, Social Search and the beginning of the App Economy
- In case you missed it, Rita McGrath’s interview about Mark Zuckerberg
